The Exotic Dancer Who Became WWI’s Most Notorious Spy

Introduction

Once Europe’s most prominent striptease performer, Dutch exotic dancer Mata Hari was executed by a French firing squad after she was found guilty of spying for the Germans during World War I.
Mata Hari and her husband Rudolph.
Mata Hari and her husband Rudolph.

Mata Hari spent much of her career claiming that she was raised as an Indian temple dancer. In reality, however, she was born Margaretha Zelle on August 7, 1876, and grew up the daughter of a haberdasher in the Dutch town of Leeuwarden. Desperate for adventure, at age 18 she answered a newspaper ad and wed a much older army captain named Rudolf MacLeod. His military career later took the couple to Indonesia, where they had two children, but their marriage was plagued by infidelity and domestic violence. Following the death of their young son, they moved back to Europe and divorced. The 27-year-old Margaretha was left impoverished. In 1903, after losing custody of her daughter, she moved to Paris and looked to start over. “I wanted to live like a colorful butterfly in the sun,” she later said.

It was in the City of Lights that Margaretha Zelle reinvented herself as an artist. Drawing on her experiences in the Dutch East Indies, she developed a “Hindu” dance act and began performing under the name “Lady Gresha MacLeod.” As part of each routine, she would cast off a series of colorful robes and veils until she was left nearly nude. “I never could dance well,” she later admitted. “People came to see me because I was the first who dared to show myself naked to the public.” To add to her mystique, Margaretha adopted the stage name “Mata Hari,” a Malay phrase meaning “eye of the day.”

Mata hari
Credit: Apic/Getty Images

Audiences were entranced by Mata Hari’s claims that her rhythmic, undulating movements were part of an ancient temple rite from the Orient, and her shows quickly became a sensation. “Mata Hari personifies all the poetry of India,” one reviewer wrote, “its mysticism, its voluptuousness, its languor, its hypnotizing charm.” Declared a “Star of Dance” in 1908, the olive-skinned beauty spent the next several years traveling Europe and performing before sold out crowds. She also began affairs with a series of military officers and wealthy aristocrats, many of whom showered her gifts and cash. “Tonight I dine with Count A and tomorrow with Duke B,” she once quipped. “If I don’t have to dance, I make a trip with Marquis C. I avoid serious liaisons.”

By 1914, however, Mata Hari’s dalliances with rich men had become a matter of financial survival. She was now nearly 40, and she had watched her dancing career slowly stagnate. Her problems only mounted with the outbreak of World War I. She was in Berlin at the time, and when she tried to travel to France, the Germans confiscated her luggage and bank accounts. She was forced to return to her neutral homeland of Holland, where she resumed an old affair with a wealthy Dutch baron.

mata hari
Credit: ullstein bild/ullstein bild via Getty Images

The details of Mata Hari’s espionage career remain sketchy, but it seems to have begun in the fall of 1915, when she was approached by Karl Kroemer, the honorary German consul in Amsterdam. Kroemer evidently considered her high-class contacts and neutral Dutch citizenship a valuable asset, so he offered her 20,000 francs to become a spy for the Kaiser. The cash-strapped dancer accepted the money—she later claimed she considered it payback for the assets seized from her a year earlier—but whether she actually took part in espionage is unclear. Whatever the case, the 39-year-old was assigned a German codename: “H 21.”

Over the next several months, Mata Hari continued traveling through Europe and carrying out flings with military officers and politicians. Her constant movements—not to mention her presence in Germany at the beginning of the war—had soon attracted the attention of British intelligence, which suspected her of being an enemy agent. After questioning Mata Hari when she passed through England, the British cautioned their French allies to watch her closely. “Although she was thoroughly searched and nothing incriminating found,” a report read, “she is regarded by Police and Military to be not above suspicion, and her subsequent movements should be watched.”

Mata Hari, c. 1910.
Mata Hari, c. 1910.

Mata Hari only sank deeper into wartime intrigue in 1916. That summer, a French intelligence operative named Georges Ladoux approached her in Paris with yet another lucrative espionage offer—this time to spy for France. Ladoux was well aware of Britain’s suspicions that she was a German agent, but he seems to have considered the recruitment a means of either entrapping her or turning her to his side. By then, Mata Hari had begun a passionate romance with Vladimir de Masloff, a 21-year-old Russian army captain. Anxious to make money to start a new life with him, she accepted Ladoux’s deal and announced her intentions to seduce military secrets out of high-ranking Germans.

Following an abortive attempt to travel to Belgium in November 1916, Mata Hari ended up in neutral Spain, where she bedded a German major named Arnold Kalle. Just what transpired between the two is the subject of much debate. The dancer evidently made a bumbling attempt to glean information from Kalle, but she may have also offered him her services as a spy. In either case, by the time she returned to Paris, a French wireless station at the Eiffel Tower had intercepted coded messages that Kalle sent to Berlin. Each of the communiqués referred to agent “H 21,” whom the French quickly identified as Mata Hari. Kalle’s messages may have been a calculated ploy to expose her—he allegedly sent the telegrams in an old code that the Germans knew the Allies had cracked—but they were all the evidence Ladoux needed. On February 13, 1917, Mata Hari was arrested, charged with espionage and confined to Paris’ infamous Saint-Lazare prison.

Mata Hari's mug shot on the day of her arrest. (Credit: adoc-photos/Corbis via Getty Images)
Mata Hari’s mug shot on the day of her arrest. (Credit: adoc-photos/Corbis via Getty Images)

When not languishing in her damp, lice-ridden cell, the dancer spent the next several months under interrogation. While she spoke frankly about her promiscuous lifestyle, she was adamant that she had never committed espionage for any country other than France. “A courtesan, I admit it,” she said. “A spy, never!” When questioned about Kalle’s messages, she came clean about accepting money from the Germans, but denied passing them any secrets. “I never considered myself a German agent with a number,” she pleaded, “because I never did anything for them.”

Mata Hari’s espionage trial commenced on July 24, 1917. Despite a lack of evidence about the secrets she might have passed to the Germans, the prosecution blamed her for the deaths of thousands of Allied soldiers and pointed to her numerous affairs as proof that she had been gathering intelligence. “The evil that this woman has done is unbelievable,” prosecutor Andre Mornet concluded in his final statement. “This is perhaps the greatest woman spy of the century.” In the end, it took a military tribunal less than an hour to find her guilty and sentence her to death.

Mata Hari on the day of her arrest.
Mata Hari on the day of her arrest.

The question of Mata Hari’s guilt continues to fascinate historians to this day. The documents from her trial were sealed for several decades, but many of the researchers who’ve since studied them have concluded that the case against her was flimsy. Most of the prosecution’s evidence was circumstantial, and her defense attorney was prevented from introducing witnesses that might have backed up her claims. While many scholars remain convinced that Mata Hari was indeed a spy, others contend that she was scapegoated or even framed in order to raise French morale during one of the darkest periods of the war. Nevertheless, the true extent of her espionage may never be known for certain.

Whether guilty or innocent, at dawn on November 17, 1917, Mata Hari was driven to a field on the outskirts of Paris. After refusing a blindfold, she was placed against a wooden stake and executed by a firing squad of twelve French soldiers. Ever the performer, she supposedly blew a kiss to the troops moments before the fatal shots rang out.

Article Details:

The Exotic Dancer Who Became WWI’s Most Notorious Spy

  • Author

    Evan Andrews

  • Website Name

    History.com

  • Year Published

    2016

  • Title

    The Exotic Dancer Who Became WWI’s Most Notorious Spy

  • URL

    http://www.history.com/news/the-exotic-dancer-who-became-wwis-most-notorious-spy

  • Access Date

    October 20, 2017

  • Publisher

    A+E Networks