The meeting of Aztec king Montezuma and Spanish conquistador Hernán Cortés on November 8, 1519, is one of the most consequential in history, affecting the welfare, beliefs and culture of millions of people living in the Western hemisphere. Yet for centuries, historians have relied on only one side of the story: the Spanish account.
It was a tidy narrative that described how Montezuma, on meeting Cortés and his retinue, swiftly surrendered his vast Indigenous empire, recognizing the divine right of the Spanish and the Catholic Church to overtake his lands and people. When violent rebellion ensued, the story goes, the Spanish retreated with hordes of gold, then returned and laid siege to the Aztec capital, securing their rightful conquest and adding to the glory of Spain with its mammoth new territory, which came to be known as Mexico.
But that account was laden with personal and political agendas. New scholarship and accounts from the Aztecs and their descendants have cast new light on the meeting that changed the course of continents. Here are four myths about the Aztecs, Montezuma and what really happened when the Spanish arrived.
Myth 1: Montezuma Was a Weak, Unsophisticated Leader
The Aztec Empire that ruled over Central Mexico from 1429 to 1521 was a triple alliance between the Indigenous Nahua city-states of Tetzcoco, Tlacopan and Tenochtitlán. More than 500 small states comprised of approximately 6 million people lived under the alliance’s rule. Montezuma was named huey tlahtoani, or king, of Tenochtitlán on September 15, 1502. “He was a warrior and well-respected military leader who maintained a vibrant city and culture, both politically and economically,” says Buddy Levy, author of Conquistador: Hernán Cortés, King Montezuma, and the Last Stand of the Aztecs. Montezuma’s empire grew in size, status and wealth despite three years of famine and three earthquakes—disasters that would topple a weaker leader.
Tenochtitlán was twice as large as Seville, the prosperous capital of southern Spain, but with 10 times as many people. Its dazzling location on an island in the center of Lake Texcoco—along with its towering pyramids and temples, vast plazas and canals that locals traversed by canoe—inspired wonder in the visiting Europeans, who had never seen a city of this scale. In a letter to Spain’s King Carlos V, Holy Roman Emperor, Cortés described bridges where “10 horses can go abreast,” and public squares with markets selling food and “jewels of gold and silver.” Montezuma’s palace complex included a zoo with aviary, art collections, armory, library, pleasure palace and botanic garden.
The Aztec ruler began studying the Spanish as soon as they landed. “The Spanish were constantly surrounded by spies who sent back information back to Montezuma. He wanted to learn more about their world, and it’s not hard to imagine that one day, the Spanish could be part of his,” says Matthew Restall, author of When Montezuma Met Cortés. “If we want to fault him, his sense of his own authority was such that he was not able to see how extensive the Spanish threat was.”
Myth 2: The Aztecs Believed the Spanish Were Gods Prophesied to Return
If it sounds too good to be true that the Spanish showed up to conquer a powerful empire and were perceived as gods fated to be its overlords, it’s because it is. “[The Aztecs] did not believe that their god Quetzalcóatl walked among them, nor were they impressed by a vision of [Christianity’s Virgin] Mary or one of the saints,” writes Rutgers University history professor Camilla Townsend in The Fifth Sun: A New History of the Aztecs.
Nor did Cortés—never shy about his exploits—ever mention in his writings that he was mistaken for Quetzalcóatl. The idea of a prophesied god returning was a Christian narrative overlaid on Aztec mythology surrounding Quetzalcoatl, says Restall, made popular in the 16th century by “Franciscans who came to convert the Nahuas to Christianity.” The Florentine Codex, written in 1555 by Nahuas educated in the Franciscan faith, emphasized this prophecy as a way to rationalize the conquest.
READ MORE: How Hernán Cortés Conquered the Aztec Empire
Myth 3: Montezuma Surrendered Immediately to the Spanish
When Cortés sailed to Mexico from Cuba, looking for territory to conquer and riches to plunder in the name of the Spanish crown, he was an outlaw defying orders from Cuban Governor Diego Velasquez, who had canceled his exploratory expedition. “Cortés had gone completely rogue,” says Levy.
His letters to King Carlos V needed to justify his disobedience and claim he followed Spanish rules of conquest—which meant giving the Aztecs an opportunity to submit to the crown and Christ.
If Montezuma had immediately surrendered, it would have been something to write home about—but no one wrote home until almost a year later, when the Spanish conquered the city by force. “Throughout the entire 235 days, neither Cortés nor any other Spaniard in Tenochtitlán wrote a letter or report to the king, or to anyone outside the city, detailing their supposed control of city and empire,” Restall writes. “Yet they claimed to have ink and paper—to notarize Montezuma’s surrender.”
Firsthand accounts by locals show Montezuma’s life continuing normally after he takes in his Spanish guests, receiving ambassadors, envoys delivering tribute and giving public speeches. In his later letters to King Carlos, Cortés even reported that Montezuma went hunting and moved around the city with a retinue “of always at least 3,000 men.” Spanish priest and historian Bartolomé de Las Casas wrote to the king and high court officials to say Montezuma’s surrender was a lie. But his letter went unheeded, as accepting the surrender was critical to justifying the siege of Tenochtitlán.
Myth 4: Smallpox Wiped Out the Aztecs
Multiple outbreaks of European-borne disease decimated the Aztecs in the decades after 1519. The largest, lasting from 1545 to 1550, killed more than 80 percent of the population. A second wave of the mysterious cocoliztli, the Nahua word for pestilence, came in 1576, bringing the death toll to between 7 and 17 million people. New research suggests that the cause may not have been smallpox, but salmonella.
Survivors were forced to adapt to life on new terms. Securing some degree of safety and possibly status required accepting Christianity and the “official” version of the meeting as part of the surrender—which is why, Restall argues, that version held sway for centuries. “The Aztec royal family continue[d] to have privileges after the conquest for generations,” he says. “They were elite, local rulers with property, wealth and power.” Montezuma’s daughter, Tecuichpochtzin, later known as Doña Isabel Moctezuma Tecuichpo, married conquistador Juan Cano. Her sons were considered Spanish nobles and their hereditary title, Duke of Moctezuma de Tultengo, is still in use.
After the conquest, few people were willing to go on the record about any wrongdoing—there were too many powerful people with something to gain, be it titles, lands, and other spoils of war. “It takes centuries to turn Tenochtitlán into Mexico City,” wrote Restall, “but only a few generations to spread a different kind of history, to tell a whole set of lies about Montezuma and the Aztecs and make them out to be historical truth.”