Yet the story had layers. The child’s mother had been romantically involved with several men at the time, including Oscar Folsom himself. With the paternity uncertain, Cleveland reportedly took responsibility—perhaps to shield the reputations of the other potential fathers, all of whom were married. This episode, which predated Frances' adolescence, did not deter her from eventually marrying Cleveland and accepting his complicated past.
Courtship in the Public Eye
By the time Cleveland took office in March 1885, his feelings for Frances had matured. Then a student at Wells College, Frances had blossomed into a celebrated beauty. With her mother’s permission, Cleveland began sending her letters and decorating her dormitory room with flowers.
He proposed in writing just after Frances’ graduation in August 1885. Their engagement remained secret until just five days before the wedding. On June 2, 1886, Frances Folsom became the First Lady of the United States in a ceremony held not in a grand church but in the intimate setting of the White House’s Blue Room.
The White House Wedding
President Cleveland worked a full day before arriving for his own wedding. The ceremony, attended by just 28 guests, included close family, friends, and cabinet members with their wives. Plump and mustachioed at 49, the president wore a tuxedo and white bowtie. Frances, only 21, wore an ivory satin gown so stiff it could stand on its own. She later had it refashioned into an evening dress for official functions and portrait sittings.
The couple requested a modern twist on their vows, replacing the traditional “honor, love and obey” with “honor, love and keep.” The ceremony was officiated by Cleveland’s brother, Reverend William Neal Cleveland, and Reverend Byron Sutherland. The U.S. Marine Band, led by John Philip Sousa, provided the musical backdrop.
From Scandal to Stardom
Until the wedding, Cleveland’s sister Rose had managed the duties of First Lady. She gladly stepped aside after the marriage to pursue a career in education. Frances, for her part, quickly won over the American public. Her charm, beauty and graciousness made her a beloved figure. She even broke tradition by holding weekly receptions on Saturday afternoons so working women could attend—an early and symbolic gesture of inclusion.