Black Showmanship and Defiance
Dance became a sign of Black social progression. Not only did eccentric dancing have a wow factor that helped catapult vaudeville acts such as tap dancer Bill Bailey onto mainstream stages and cinema, it signified that more Black people had access to shoes, a material source that some didn’t have prior to the 20th century. Shoes were critical to what tappers commonly referred to as a skate, a move that bears some resemblance to the moonwalk.
Dance innovations in the years of the Great Migration (early 1900s) and the Harlem Renaissance (1910s through the mid-1930s) exemplified a shift toward Black autonomy and showmanship, as well as a greater evolution of social dance led by the younger generation.
“The idea is that when we move away from the plantation life and we get to the city, suddenly we can control our bodies,” says Thomas F. DeFrantz, a professor at Northwestern University. “And that means if we’re young, usually, then we want to be out of control: ‘I’m gonna show you all the things I can do.’”
In 1926, W.E.B. Du Bois’ essay “Criteria of Negro Art” challenged the idea that art should be judged through a white, Eurocentric lens. As a sociologist and civil rights leader, he believed Black artists had a responsibility to create work that countered degrading representations such as “Uncle Toms, Topsies, good ‘darkies’ and clowns.” With a history rooted in humor and exaggerated performance, forerunners of the moonwalk were seen as “buffooney,” Das explains, and were sidelined in favor of more “serious” art at the time.