More Hazardous Duties
In 1967, the program moved to a San Diego facility now known as the Naval Information Warfare Center Pacific (NIWC Pacific), where it remains headquartered. Its work soon expanded to study dolphins’ brain function, sensory organs and vocalizations. Handlers also trained dolphins and sea lions to detect, locate, mark and recover objects such as mines—dolphins using echolocation, sea lions their exceptional directional hearing and low-light vision.
As recently as 2013, a Navy dolphin on a training mission happened across a rare 19th-century Howell torpedo that had been lost off San Diego in 1899. Its recovered fragments are being prepared for display at the U.S. Naval Undersea Museum, in Keyport, Washington. That museum also boasts displays honoring Tuffy the bottlenose dolphin, whom it dubs the program’s “star pupil” for his ability to master complicated tasks. In 1965, the Navy loaned Tuffy to its SEALAB II underwater habitat 200 feet under the ocean off the coast of San Diego, where the dolphin ferried supplies to and from surface supply ships, among other tasks.
Another highly successful application has been the use of bottlenose dolphins for force protection—specifically, to detect inbound enemy swimmers and vehicles, particularly in rough inshore waters, where poor acoustics often defeat electronic detection devices. “They have this extraordinary ability to find objects amidst all of the noise, seaweed and low-visibility environment,” said Walter. The Navy deployed dolphins for this purpose to Vietnam in 1970–71, the Persian Gulf in 1987–88 (toward the end of the Iran-Iraq War) and the Persian Gulf again in 2003–05 (for the War in Afghanistan and the Iraq War). They also patrolled San Diego Bay in 1996 during the Republican National Convention.
Sea lions, meanwhile, have excelled at recovering test ordnance fired into the ocean. The unarmed objects are fitted with acoustic beacons the animal can detect. The sea lion then returns to the surface to accept a bite plate connected to a recovery device. Finally, it dives down, attaches the device to the ordnance and returns topside for a fishy reward while the object is winched up to the boat.
Positive Reinforcement or Punishment?
Despite its decades of success, the NMMP has faced criticism. Opponents argue the mammals face unnatural stressors, confinement and such behavioral control measures as anti-foraging muzzles.
Program officials counter that handlers use muzzles strictly to prevent dolphins from ingesting harmful objects. In fact, they say, food is less motivating than play (handlers often reward dolphins with splashes, tickles and encouragement to frolic). Punishment, they note, only leads to refusal.
Most training, they say, takes place untethered in the open ocean, and only a handful of dolphins have failed to return to their open-mesh enclosures over the years. Supporters argue it’s more humane to keep them in the program than return them to the wild.
According to Navy statistics, the program’s dolphins live about twice as long as their wild counterparts, its sea lions up to three times longer—thanks in large measure to attentive handlers, regular veterinary care and diets based on each species’ natural foods.
“Each animal is teamed with a small crew of professionals devoted to that animal,” says Darian L. Wilson, public affairs director at NIWC Pacific. “A team of more than a dozen veterinarians oversees their medical care, providing everything from semiannual preventative physicals to treatment for acute conditions, as well as their nutrition.” Their care is regulated by federal marine mammal protection and animal welfare laws.