Skip to main content

By: Ratha Tep

How the Salem Witch Trials Inspired Arthur Miller’s Attack on McCarthyism

Written at the height of the Red Scare, The Crucible drew parallels between the Salem witch trials and the political persecution of the 1950s.

Image from 'The Crucible' (1996) starring Daniel Day-Lewis.

Alamy Stock Photo
Published: November 17, 2026Last Updated: November 17, 2026

Takeaways

  • The Crucible explores mass hysteria, persecution and integrity through the Salem witch trials.

  • Arthur Miller wrote The Crucible as an allegory for McCarthyism and the Red Scare.

  • Elia Kazan's testimony before the House Un-American Activities Committee inspired Miller.

  • The Crucible reflected Miller's personal struggles and remains one of his most popular plays.

By the early 1950s, Arthur Miller was one of America’s leading playwrights, known for Broadway hits such as “All My Sons” (1947) and “Death of a Salesman” (1949), which won him a Pulitzer Prize.

As anticommunist investigations swept across Cold War America, Miller found himself drawn to an unexpected subject for a new project: the Salem witch trials. Miller had been fascinated by the 1692 witch hunt ever since he studied it in an American history course at the University of Michigan. The witchcraft accusations that gripped colonial Massachusetts led to the hanging of 19 people, mostly women. Yet, Miller initially considered the events too farfetched to bring to the stage.

“Nobody could be made to believe that people in a small village in 17th-century Massachusetts would start killing each other over whether someone was a witch or not,” Miller recalled in an interview with biographer Christopher Bigsby for the book Arthur Miller: 1915-1962. 

But as events unfolded in Washington in the late 1940s and ’50s, Miller recognized unsettling echoes of Salem. He drew on that history for “The Crucible,” his 1953 play mirroring the fear and persecution that occurred during the second Red Scare. 

Red Scare

Historian Yohuru Williams explains how the fear of communist influences in America grew into a phenomenon known as "the Red Scare."

1:46m watch

The Second Red Scare, McCarthyism and HUAC

America’s first Red Scare followed the 1917 Bolshevik Revolution in Russia, as fears of communism and anarchism fueled a crackdown on suspected radicals. The crackdown culminated in the Palmer Raids of 1919 and 1920, when federal authorities arrested thousands of suspected radicals, often without warrants or sufficient evidence, and deported hundreds of immigrants.

After World War II, fears of Soviet espionage and communist infiltration sparked a new wave of anticommunist fervor. The House Un-American Activities Committee (HUAC), a congressional panel with subpoena power, held highly publicized hearings that investigated suspected communists, particularly in Hollywood. Witnesses were questioned about their political affiliations and were pressured to identify others with communist ties. Refusing to cooperate could mean professional ruin.

In 1947, ten Hollywood writers and directors who defied HUAC were cited for contempt of Congress. They were subsequently blacklisted by major studios and served prison sentences. Subsequently, Senator Joseph McCarthy rose to prominence in 1950 by launching accusations of communist infiltration in the federal government. His aggressive tactics, including public accusations, intimidation and guilt by association, became so closely tied with the era’s anticommunist investigations that the practice became known as McCarthyism. To Miller, the pressure to confess and identify others bore an eerie resemblance to the Salem witch trials. 

“There were trials taking place in the United States in 1949–50, where I heard actual lines being spoken by American prosecutors which I vaguely remembered from reading about the witchcraft in 1692,” Miller recalled. “At first, it was simply unbelievable, but I went back into history and there it was. It was mind-boggling that the same material could have arisen some 300 years later.”

U.S. Senator Joseph McCarthy in front of U.S. Capitol, Washington D.C., poses to show how he'll sweep communists out of government, 1954.

Photo by: Universal History Archive/Universal Images Group via Getty Images

U.S. Senator Joseph McCarthy in front of U.S. Capitol, Washington D.C., poses to show how he'll sweep communists out of government, 1954.

Photo by: Universal History Archive/Universal Images Group via Getty Images

The Personal Betrayal That Shaped ‘The Crucible’

In April 1952, just as Miller was planning a research trip to Salem, he received a call from his friend and collaborator Elia Kazan, who had directed the Broadway productions of “All My Sons” and “Death of a Salesman.”

Kazan had previously testified before HUAC without identifying former Communist Party associates. When they met up, Kazan told Miller he planned to cooperate with the investigations, fearing that continued resistance would destroy his Hollywood career.

“Kazan was in a different position than Miller—as a director, he either named names or stopped working in Hollywood,” says Thomas Doherty, a professor of American studies at Brandeis University and author of Show Trial: Hollywood, HUAC, and the Birth of the Blacklist. “There was no blacklist on Broadway, so Miller could work if he defied the committee.”

According to Bigsby, Miller was troubled by Kazan’s attempt to justify his decision as a moral act. He also worried that others who remembered him at Communist meetings might one day name Miller, too. The encounter strained their friendship and sharpened the central moral dilemma of “The Crucible”: whether to betray others to save oneself.

Playwright Arthur Miller with director Elia Kazan, circa 1955.

Photo by FPG/Hulton Archive/Getty Images

Playwright Arthur Miller with director Elia Kazan, circa 1955.

Photo by FPG/Hulton Archive/Getty Images

Turning the Salem Witch Trials Into ‘The Crucible’

In Salem, Miller pored over historical court records, looking for a way to dramatize the trials. A breakthrough came when he read testimony from Elizabeth Proctor’s hearing, in which her young accuser, Abigail Williams, had tried to strike her, only to cry out that her hand had been burned.

Miller interpreted the incident as evidence of a personal vendetta. He fantasized that Williams had been having an affair with Elizabeth’s husband, John Proctor, and accused Elizabeth of witchcraft to get her out of the picture. Although there is no historical evidence of such a relationship, the supposed entanglement became central to “The Crucible.”

Miller later acknowledged that his own marital troubles influenced the storyline. While married to his first wife, Mary, he had become infatuated with Marilyn Monroe after meeting her in 1951. “My own marriage of 12 years was teetering and I knew more than I wished to know about where the blame lay,” he wrote in a 1996 essay for The New Yorker. Miller and Monroe married in 1956.

In the play, Proctor struggles with guilt over his infidelity before being accused of witchcraft himself. Facing execution, he initially agrees to confess but refuses to name others as witches or surrender his signed confession to the court, choosing to die rather than sacrifice his integrity.

Paul Scofield and Winona Ryder in 'The Crucible' (1996).

Alamy Stock Photo

Paul Scofield and Winona Ryder in 'The Crucible' (1996).

Alamy Stock Photo

The Enduring Legacy of ‘The Crucible’

When “The Crucible” opened on Broadway on January 22, 1953, its political message was unmistakable. “Everyone understood immediately that a play about Salem in 1692 was a transparent allegory for HUAC/McCarthyism,” Doherty says. “You’d have to be a pretty dense theatergoer in New York in 1953 not to pick up on the connections—in fact, you probably bought a ticket to show your opposition to HUAC and McCarthy,” he adds.

Yet the production initially received mixed reviews. “Many found the play’s Salem Witch trials analogy to the work of Congress unfair and unpatriotic,” says Susan C. W. Abbotson, a professor of English at Rhode Island College and author of Critical Companion to Arthur Miller: A Literary Reference to His Life and Work. Some journalists, she adds, “seemed wary of praising the play in case it led them to be decried as un-American.” Other critics rejected the comparison outright, arguing that witches do not exist, while communists do.

Three years later, Miller faced his own confrontation with HUAC. Summoned before the committee in June 1956, he refused to identify others who had attended communist-related meetings. According to Abbotson, a former president of the Arthur Miller Society, the parallel between the committee’s tactics and those depicted in “The Crucible” was so striking that “Miller virtually quotes John Proctor’s dialogue at his own congressional hearing in 1956,” she says. “Like his play’s protagonist, Miller also refused to go along with a confession that would hurt other people. Miller saw himself, like Proctor, taking a stand against the tyranny of his community.”

Miller was convicted of contempt of Congress in 1957, but his conviction was overturned the following year.

Over time, “The Crucible” became Miller’s most frequently performed play, resonating with audiences far beyond Cold War America. Although its political parallels were intentional, Miller’s “real goal went far beyond responding to McCarthyism,” says Abbotson. He wanted to create, as she explains, “a universal drama reflecting the struggle of any individual between selfishness and doing the right thing.”

Related

1950s

9 videos

Rand’s novels helped transform objectivism into a movement.

The tragedy of Pan Am Flight 526A helped pave the way for safety briefings and other measures passengers know today.

It came. It thawed. It conquered. Along the way, the frozen meal in a box had multiple creators.

About the author

Ratha Tep

Ratha Tep, based in Dublin, is a frequent contributor to The New York Times. She also writes books for children.

Fact Check

We strive for accuracy and fairness. But if you see something that doesn't look right, click here to contact us! HISTORY reviews and updates its content regularly to ensure it is complete and accurate.

Citation Information

Article Title
How the Salem Witch Trials Inspired Arthur Miller’s Attack on McCarthyism
Author
Ratha Tep
Website Name
History
Date Accessed
November 17, 2026
Publisher
A&E Television Networks
Last Updated
November 17, 2026
Original Published Date
November 17, 2026
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement