A botched burglary attempt further clouds one of the earliest kidnap-for-ransom cases. As he was about to go to bed, wealthy New Yorker Holmes Van Brunt heard burglars breaking into his brother’s house next door. After rounding up three other men to help him surprise the intruders, Van Brunt engaged the thieves in a shotgun battle that left the robbers severely wounded. As he lay dying, one of the burglars, Joseph Douglas, confessed that he had been responsible for kidnapping four-year-old Charley Ross earlier in the year. He then promised that the child would be returned alive.