Failures in Government Response
Many residents of New Orleans–with their homes beneath floodwaters–had nowhere to go. At the Superdome, where supplies were limited to begin with, officials accepted 15,000 more refugees from the storm on Monday before locking the doors. Tens of thousands of people desperate for food, water and shelter broke into the Ernest N. Morial Convention Center complex, where they found nothing but chaos.
Meanwhile, it was nearly impossible to leave New Orleans: People without cars or anyplace to go were stuck. Some people, for example, tried to walk over the Crescent City Connection bridge to the nearby suburb of Gretna, but armed police officers forced them to turn back.
Katrina also pummeled huge areas of Louisiana, Mississippi and Alabama, but the desperation was most concentrated in New Orleans. Before the storm, the city’s population was mostly black (about 67 percent); moreover, nearly 30 percent of its people lived in poverty. Katrina exacerbated these conditions and left many of New Orleans’s poorest citizens even more vulnerable than they had been before the storm.
How Many People Died in Hurricane Katrina?
Estimates vary, but Hurricane Katrina is believed to have caused between 1,200 and 2,000 deaths, including indirect deaths such as shootings, suicides, drug overdoses and gas-poisoning deaths. Days after the hurricane struck, bodies were still being recovered from inside flooded buildings and pockets of floodwaters.
Some deaths–which may have been preventable–resulted in years-long investigations, such as the deaths of 215 sick and elderly patients at hospitals and long-term care facilities in southern Louisiana.
Katrina and its high winds and rainfall affected some 90,000 square miles of the United States, from the Gulf Coast to the Great Lakes. Hundreds of thousands of evacuees scattered far and wide, often settling in cities like Houston, San Antonio, Baton Rogue and Atlanta. According to The Data Center, an independent research organization in New Orleans, the storm ultimately displaced more than 1 million people in the Gulf Coast region.
The population of New Orleans plummeted in the aftermath of Katrina: By 2006 it had fallen to a low of about 230,000 people–less than half of its pre-Katrina population. It has since rebounded to about 386,000 residents, but the Crescent City remains short of its previous population level.
Political Fallout From Hurricane Katrina
In the wake of the storm's devastating effects, local, state and federal governments were criticized for their slow, inadequate response, as well as for the levee failures around New Orleans. And officials from different branches of government were quick to direct the blame at each other.
"We wanted soldiers, helicopters, food and water," Denise Bottcher, press secretary for Governor Kathleen Blanco of Louisiana told the New York Times. "They wanted to negotiate an organizational chart."
Mayor Nagin argued that there was no clear designation of who was in charge, telling reporters, “The state and federal government are doing a two-step dance."
President Bush originally praised his director of FEMA, Michael D. Brown, infamously declaring "Brownie, you're doing a heck of a job." But as criticism mounted and glaring inadequacies were exposed, Brown was forced to resign, as was the New Orleans Police Department Superintendent.
Governor Blanco declined to seek re-election in 2007 and Mayor Nagin left office in 2010. In 2014 Nagin was convicted of bribery, fraud and money laundering while in office.
Despite adequate warning 56 hours before landfall, Governor Blanco and Mayor Nagin delayed ordering a mandatory evacuation in New Orleans until 19 hours before landfall.
The incomplete pre-landfall evacuation led to deaths, thousands of dangerous rescues, and horrible conditions for those who remained.
Given the well-known consequences of a major hurricane striking New Orleans, [Dept. of Homeland Security Secretary Michael Chertoff] should have designated an Incident of National Significance no later than Saturday, two days prior to landfall, when the National Weather Service predicted New Orleans would be struck by a Category 4 or 5 hurricane.
The collapse of local law enforcement and lack of effective public communications led to civil unrest and further delayed relief.
Medical care and evacuations suffered from a lack of advance preparations, inadequate communications, and difficulties coordinating efforts.
Long-standing weaknesses and the magnitude of the disaster overwhelmed FEMA’s ability to provide emergency shelter and temporary housing.
Changes Since Katrina
The dismal failures in preparation for Katrina, and in the response during and after the disaster, spurred a series of reforms initiated by Congress. Chief among them was a requirement that all levels of government train to execute coordinated plans of disaster response. In the decade following Katrina, FEMA paid out billions in grants to ensure better preparedness.
Meanwhile, the Army Corps of Engineers built an improved, $14 billion network of levees and floodwalls around New Orleans. The agency said the work ensured the city's safety from flooding for the time being. But the Army Corps also stated that, in the face of a changing climate, rising sea levels and the loss of protective barrier islands, the system will fall short of providing long-term protection without significant routine upgrades.
Sources