Every holiday season, parents around the world face the same daunting question: What plaything will make my child light up? As the 20th century progressed and kids became increasingly exposed to radio and television advertising, chances were good their wish lists included the season’s “hot” toy. From simple classics like stuffed teddy bears and yo-yos to more high-tech diversions like gaming consoles, here's a look back at some of the most popular holiday toys of the last century. 

1. 1910s — Teddy Bear

christmas, christmas toys, teddy bear
Getty Images / LisaValder / iStockphoto.com

The story behind the teddy bear toy goes back to 1902 when President Theodore Roosevelt refused to shoot a tied-up, defenseless black bear during a hunting trip in Mississippi. After Brooklyn shopkeeper Morris Mictom saw a political cartoon about the incident, he and his wife made a stuffed fabric “Teddy’s bear” and put it in their shop window, sparking immediate customer interest. 

Around the same time, a family-owned toy company in Germany began making stuffed bears of its own. Bought in bulk by a U.S. manufacturer, the German bears officially became known as teddy bears in 1906. Other companies jumped on the bandwagon, launching an international teddy craze that hasn’t really stopped since.

Honorable mention: Erector sets, Lionel trains

2. 1920s — Yo-Yo

All hail the Yo-Yo! This classic is actually an ancient invention that originated in China circa 1000 B.C. Or was it ancient Greece? The Philippines? Historians may be divided on the exact location, but variations of the spinning-disk-on-a-string toy had certainly been around for centuries before 1928, when Pedro Flores began manufacturing the Yo-Yo in the United States, calling it by its Filipino name. Flores soon sold his toy company to a competitor, Don Duncan, a marketing whiz whose promotional Yo-Yo trick contests would launch the toy’s popularity into the stratosphere. 

Honorable mention: Tinker Toys, Raggedy Ann

3. 1930s — Shirley Temple doll

christmas, christmas toys, shirley temple
Getty Images / Imagno
Shirley Temple holding her namesake doll, 1937. 

Those curls, those dimples…who wouldn’t want a doll version of Shirley Temple? The Ideal Toy and Novelty Company began manufacturing the Shirley Temple doll for Christmas in 1934. Based on America’s favorite child star, Temple's hit movie “Bright Eyes” was released just after the holiday. 

Only six years old at the time, Temple already had some 20 films under her tiny belt. 

By singing, dancing and being generally adorable, Temple helped countless people escape their worries during the Great Depression when they desperately needed to. Priced at around $3 to $5 (a large sum of money at the time) the dolls made some $45 million for Ideal over seven years of production and enjoyed an afterlife as prized collectors’ items: As of 2010, an original Shirley Temple doll was worth more than $1,500 on eBay.

Honorable mention: Monopoly, Red Ryder BB gun

4. 1940s — Slinky

christmas, christmas toys, slinky
jeff5150 / iStockphoto.com

This cheap, outrageously fun little toy was invented and launched just in time for Christmas 1945. Mechanical engineer Richard James had stumbled on the inspiration for the Slinky after accidentally knocking over some ship springs he was working on, which “walked” instead of falling. James came up with a machine that coiled 80 feet of wire into a 2-inch spiral, his wife gave it the name “Slinky” and a legend was born. 

After Christmas demonstrations at Gimbels Department Store in Philadelphia, the first 400 Slinkys sold within minutes. Seventy years—and more than 300 million Slinkys—later, the toy remains a popular seller.

Honorable mention: LEGOs, Silly Putty

5. 1950s — Mr. Potato Head

christmas, christmas toys, mr potato head
Getty Images / Mario Ruiz / The LIFE Images Collection

Inventor George Lerner turned to the family dinner table for inspiration for this classic: Though many kids don’t like to eat their vegetables, they might want to play with them instead. Lerner originally created a bunch of silly face parts to be used with actual potatoes and other vegetables (beets anyone?) as part of a cereal box promotion. 

The Hassenfeld brothers, future founders of Hasbro Inc., purchased the toy idea in 1952, packaging 28 plastic facial and body parts with a styrofoam head, which was later changed to plastic as well. By the end of its first year, Mr. Potato Head made history as the first toy with its own TV commercial (catchphrase: “Can I have that? I want that!”) and generated more than $4 million in sales.

Honorable mention: Hula Hoop, Barbie, Play-Doh, Tonka Trunks (The ‘50s was a golden age for toys!)

6. 1960s — G.I. Joe

christmas, christmas toys, GI Joe
Getty Images / Justin Sullivan
The prototype for the G.I. Joe action figure, “Rocky the Paratrooper.”

Introduced as a kind of male counterpart to Mattel’s iconic Barbie, Government-Issue Joe (as ordinary soldiers were known during World War II) was marketed to little boys as an “action figure,” not a doll. Hasbro launched the first generation of foot-tall G.I. Joe figures—available in Action Soldier, Pilot, Marine and Sailor—at the height of the Cold War, to massive success. 

In 1970, amid growing protest over U.S. involvement in Vietnam, G.I. Joe was reinvented as more of an adventurer, and later as a space traveler, but no one much liked these changes. 

G.I. Joe went into retirement in 1978, but roared back into action (in a shrunken, 3 ¾-inch size) in the 1980s after the tremendous success of Star Wars made action figures cool again. He’s been around ever since, spawning comics, a TV series, video games and a feature film (2009’s “G.I. Joe: Rise of the Cobra”).

Honorable mention: Etch-a-Sketch, Easy Bake Oven, Playmobil

7. 1970s — Star Wars action figures

christmas, christmas toys, star wars
jpgfactory / iStockphoto.com

No one predicted the massive success of George Lucas’ “Star Wars,” released by 20th Century Fox in May 1977. By Christmas of that year, toy company Kenner hadn’t even started production on movie-related action figures. Instead, lucky children unwrapped vouchers to be redeemed for 3.75-inch versions of Luke Skywalker, Princess Leia, Hans Solo, Chewbacca, Darth Vader and more than 100 other characters. These became the first Star Wars action figures. 

Released in 1978, Star Wars action figures sold briskly until 1985; they were relaunched in the mid-1990s ahead of the release of three more installments in the space saga. Now, with new installments to the franchise including “Episode VII: The Force Awakens," Star Wars is hotter than ever, and original 1978 figures are collector’s items worth up to $200,000.

Honorable mention: NERF ball, Speak and Spell

8. 1980s — Cabbage Patch Kids

christmas, christmas toys, cabbage patch dolll
Original Appalachian Artworks, Inc.
A 1983 Cabbage Patch Doll. 

Named after the time-old fable that children are picked from cabbage patches, these dolls were an instant hit. For Christmas 1983, all bets were off. Every kid wanted to “adopt” one of Coleco’s squishy-faced Cabbage Patch Kids dolls, and parents were willing to take extreme steps (Pushing! Shoving! Fist fights!) to make it happen. As Cabbage Patch mania swept the nation, the dolls sold on the black market for 10 times their retail price of $25. (Today, an original Cabbage Patch Kids doll can cost thousands of dollars.)

By the end of the first year in 1983, three million Cabbage Patch Kids were sold (adopted). The product continued to exceed all expectations in 1984 resulting in $2.5 billion in retail sales. Though the craze eventually subsided, and the company went bankrupt in 1988 after costly failed ventures in video and computer games, Cabbage Patch Kids are still available from Wicked Cool Toys. Babyland General Hospital in Cleveland, Georgia, home of the Cabbage Patch Kids, is the only place in the world where you can witness the birth of a hand-sculpted doll.

Honorable mention: Rubik’s Cube, Transformers, Koosh ball, Teddy Ruxpin

9. 1990s — Beanie Babies and Tickle Me Elmo

christmas, christmas toys, tickle me elmo
Getty Images / James Keyser / The LIFE Images Collection

Parents of young children in 1996 were hit with a double Christmas whammy of must-have toys. Tickle Me Elmo, a stuffed version of the popular Sesame Street character that giggled when squeezed, caused a Cabbage Patch Kid-style frenzy that year, complete with stampeding crowds and injured store workers. If his belly was squeezed, the original Elmo doll would say "Oh, boy! That tickles!"

Meanwhile, Beanie Babies, squishy stuffed animals with cute names, had enjoyed respectable sales for several years before toymaker H. Ty Warner decided to “retire” some of the successful animals, instantly turning them into hot commodities. Warner racked up more than $250 million in sales by the end of 1996, as kids and parents scoured the stores that Christmas season for the soon-to-be-collectibles, often settling for new, less sought-after babies instead. Among the rarest additions to the collection is Curly the Bear, which once sold on eBay for nearly $15,000

Honorable mention: Furby, Nintendo Game Boy

10. 2000s — Wii

christmas, christmas toys
ABDESIGN / iStockphoto.com

The history of Nintendo's Wii starts in 2006 when the company first introduced this affordable, family-friendly game console alternative, featuring wireless remote controllers and other cool new features. Holiday shoppers waited for hours for the Wii, which was cheaper than its competition (Sony PlayStation 3 and Microsoft X-Box 360), and by Christmas, Nintendo had sold some three million units. Despite reported cases of tennis elbow among early adopters, the Wii emerged victorious among its generation of game consoles, selling more than 100 million units in its seven-year run.

Honorable mention: Razor Scooter, Bratz dolls, Webkinz, Zhu Zhu Pets

WATCH: Full episodes of 'The Toys That Built America' premiere Sundays at 9/8c and stream the next day.